Source · Video

New Lawyer Advice: Overcoming Imposter Syndrome | Ali Katz | New Law Business Model

2021-10-06 5:36 YouTube

A new lawyer discusses struggling with imposter syndrome during a 15-minute consultation with non-US citizen clients who questioned her experience. Expert Ali Katz coaches her on finding the balance between collapse (imposter syndrome) and posturing (arrogance), guiding her toward an honest, dignified response that acknowledges her newness while reassuring clients she can still serve them well.

Key moments5

  1. 0:02Referral Success and a Troubling ConsultationThe attorney shares that referrals from BNI and a LinkedIn financial planner are coming in, but one recent 15-minute appointment with a non-US citizen couple left her unsettled.
  2. 0:49Imposter Syndrome Kicks InWhen the couple asked about her experience with non-US citizens, imposter syndrome took over and she failed to close the appointment by not scheduling a follow-up meeting.
  3. 2:26Collapse vs. Posture — Finding the BalanceAli Katz introduces the framework of humility vs. dignity, explaining that collapsing under pressure and posturing are both failure modes, and the goal is to simply be with what is true.
  4. 5:53What Clients Actually Care AboutAli reframes the clients' question: they don't care about years of experience, they care that a stranger they're trusting with their family's future won't make a mistake.
  5. 6:58A Script for Honest, Dignified ResponseAli coaches the attorney on language that honestly acknowledges being newer in the practice area while confidently explaining how she ensures she can still serve complex situations.

The story

  1. Before

    A new attorney received a referral lead — a non-US citizen couple — but when they asked about her experience, imposter syndrome kicked in and she collapsed, failing to close the appointment.

  2. The turning point

    Ali Katz reframes the clients' real concern (not years of experience, but trust that a stranger won't harm their family) and offers a dignified, honest script for acknowledging newness while still demonstrating competence.

  3. After

    The attorney gains a concrete language framework for handling the experience question with balance — neither collapsing in shame nor posturing with false confidence.

Teachings8

Framework

  • We're always in this balance between humility and dignity — too much humility results in imposter syndrome, and too much dignity results in arrogance.

    reflective2:26

Principles

  • Posturing is the opposite of collapse. What we're looking for is that balance between collapse and posture where you're just actually being with what's true.

    practical2:34
  • They poked at your imposter syndrome, and in the face of that poke you collapsed. It's important that we call things as they are so you can learn from this experience.

    direct1:40
  • Clients don't care about your years of experience — they care that a stranger they're trusting with their family's future doesn't screw up.

    practical5:53

Warning

  • When people have an insecurity they'll posture. So posturing is the opposite of collapse — and neither is where you want to be.

    cautionary2:26

Strategys

  • When asked about experience, acknowledge it honestly: 'I am a newer attorney in this practice area, and so it makes sense to me that you would be asking about my experience — and here's how I address that to make sure I am absolutely able to serve you, even though your situation is a bit more complex.'

    practical6:58
  • Reflect the client's real concern back to them: 'That question really makes sense because you want to make sure you're working with somebody that's going to be able to take care of your family if something happens to you.'

    practical6:30

Story

  • Failing to close the appointment — not saying 'let's go ahead and set up a time to meet' — is the concrete consequence of collapsing under imposter syndrome.

    reflective2:20

What you'll learn2

Clips from this episode8

  • Referrals from BNI and strategic partners like a financial planner on LinkedIn can be a reliable source of leads for a new attorney building a practice.

  • Too much humility results in imposter syndrome, and too much dignity results in arrogance — what we're looking for is the balance between collapse and posture where you're just actually being with what's true.

  • When a prospect pokes at your imposter syndrome and you collapse in the face of that poke, you lose the engagement — it's important to call things as they are so you can learn from the experience.

  • Being part of a group of attorneys where you can find answers to questions you don't yet know is a credible resource to mention to prospects who question your experience.

  • Co-counseling with a more experienced attorney — such as an international tax attorney with 40 years of experience — is a legitimate and powerful way to address gaps in your own experience when speaking with prospects.

  • When people have an insecurity, they'll often posture — posturing is the opposite of collapse, and neither is what we want.

  • Clients asking about your experience are really asking a question behind the question: 'Are you going to screw up with my family?' — they care about their outcome, not your resume.

  • A dignified, honest response to an experience question sounds like: 'I am a newer attorney in this practice area, and so it makes sense to me that you would be asking about my experience — here's how I address that to make sure I am absolutely able to serve you even though your situation is a bit more complex.'