Source · Video
Alexis Neely on HLN: Custody and DNA Questions - Michael Jackson Paternity Insights
Family law attorney Alexis Neely explains the legal implications of the alleged paternity of Michael Jackson's children by Dr. Arnold Klein, clarifying that Michael Jackson is legally the father for all purposes due to his name on the birth certificate and the marital presumption of paternity. She discusses whether Dr. Klein could be compelled to take a DNA test (he cannot), and how custody decisions are ultimately governed by the best interests of the children, not solely by the guardian named in a will.
Key moments4
- 0:04Can the Alleged Biological Father Make a Legal Claim?Alexis Neely explains that because Michael Jackson is listed on the birth certificate, any alleged biological father has no legal standing to claim paternity and would have little incentive to do so.
- 1:30How California Law Treats Paternity on the Birth CertificateNeely clarifies that California presumes the husband is the father when a child is born during marriage, and listing him on the birth certificate locks in that legal status permanently.
- 2:42Guardianship, the Will, and the Children's Best InterestsNeely explains that naming a guardian in a will creates only a presumption — a judge is not bound by it and will ultimately decide based on the best interests of the children, including potentially hearing from the children themselves.
- 3:27Can the Children or a Court Compel a DNA Test?Neely concludes that neither the children nor a court can legally compel Dr. Arnold Klein to submit to DNA testing, though the children could approach him privately, especially for health reasons.
Teachings8
Principles
From a legal perspective, it's completely and totally irrelevant at this point whether he is the father. Michael Jackson will be deemed to be their daddy for all legal purposes.
authoritative0:42Because he's also listed on the birth certificate, it's locked in. He's the father.
definitive1:35It really comes down to what is in the best interests of the children. And if they can speak to that themselves, that's definitely something that the court is going to listen to.
practical2:55I don't see a scenario in which he's going to be compelled at all. I don't see any situation in which he'll be compelled to give up his DNA and be linked as their actual father.
definitive3:27
Definition
When two people are married and the wife gives birth during the marriage, the person that she's married to is presumptively the father, even if he's not the biological father.
practical1:30
Warning
Just because you name a guardian does not mean that the judge has to obey what you say. It's a presumption that if you name a guardian, that's who's going to take custody of your kids.
cautionary2:42
Strategy
They could certainly go to him and say, 'Hey, Uncle Arie, are you really our dad?' and have a real heart-to-heart with him one-on-one, which again, they may want to do for health considerations if he really is their father.
practical3:50
Tip
From a health perspective, it's a good idea for us to know that anyway — knowing biological parentage can help down the road if there's any health problems that were passed down.
practical1:15
What you'll learn2
Clips from this episode13
If a biological father entered into an arrangement and the other person appears on the birth certificate, it is not in the biological father's legal interest to make a claim.
From a legal perspective, it is completely and totally irrelevant whether Dr. Klein is the biological father — Michael Jackson will be deemed to be their daddy for all legal purposes.
Biology plays a huge role in California, but when two people are married and the wife gives birth during the marriage, the person she's married to is presumptively the father, even if he's not the biological father.
Because Michael Jackson is also listed on the birth certificate, it's locked in — he's the father, even after he passes away.
Michael Jackson determined who would take care of his kids in his will, and Katherine Jackson is the named guardian.
A judge would absolutely want to hear from all of the kids if they are able to speak, because it is ultimately what is in the best interest of the child.
Just because you name a guardian does not mean that the judge has to obey what you say — it's a presumption, but it really comes down to what is in the best interests of the children.
There is no scenario in which Dr. Klein would be legally compelled to take a DNA test — it will likely always remain something private.
Children probably would not be able to go to court and ask the court to force a potential biological father to do a DNA test.
Knowing the biological father's identity could be important for health considerations — it could help the children down the road if there are any health problems that were passed down.
People think that biological paternity overrides legal paternity, especially if the biological father comes forward.. Actually, When a man is listed on the birth certificate and was married to the mother at the time of birth, he is legally the father for all purposes, regardless of biological paternity.
People think that if a named guardian is specified in a will, the court must honor that choice.. Actually, Naming a guardian creates only a presumption — the judge is not obligated to follow it and will ultimately decide based on the best interests of the children.
People think Michael Jackson's children could compel a potential biological father to take a DNA test through the courts.. Actually, They are unlikely to be able to force a DNA test through the courts; they could only approach the person privately.
