Source · Video
DIY your Bathroom, NOT your Will
This content warns against using DIY or pre-printed will forms by illustrating a real Florida court case where a woman's estate was distributed contrary to her wishes because her self-drafted will was inadequate. The case of Ann Aldrich of Keystone Heights, Florida demonstrates how the cost of litigation from a poorly drafted will can far exceed the cost of hiring an estate attorney. The key lesson is that consulting a knowledgeable lawyer to draft a will is essential to ensuring your assets pass to the people you intend.
Key moments5
- 0:00The DIY Will Danger IntroducedThe host poses the question of what can go wrong with a do-it-yourself will and sets up the cautionary story.
- 0:19Anne Aldrich's StoryAnne Aldrich of Keystone Heights, Florida used a commercially available will form in 2014, leaving property to her sister Mary and brother James — a seemingly simple arrangement that quickly became complicated.
- 0:40The Legal Battle and Unintended OutcomeAfter Mary died first and then Anne died, Anne's nieces sued over the inheritance, leading to years of court battles that ultimately awarded assets to people Anne likely never intended to inherit them.
- 1:51The Court's Verdict on DIY WillsThe court explicitly blamed the use of a pre-printed commercial form for the unfortunate outcome, invoking the adage 'pennywise and pound foolish' to warn against skipping legal counsel.
- 3:17The Real Cost of Saving MoneyThe host summarizes the lesson: Anne's attempt to save money backfired catastrophically, and viewers are urged to get educated and seek professional help to protect their families.
Teachings9
Warnings
What could go wrong with a do-it-yourself will? Well, a lot of things.
cautionary0:04The time, effort, and expense of extensive litigation undertaken to prove a testator's true intent after the testator's death can necessitate the expenditure of much more substantial amounts in attorney's fees than was avoided during the testator's life by the use of a pre-printed form.
cautionary2:36If your will is not drafted properly, your assets could pass on to somebody not even named in the document.
cautionary3:12
Storys
The court wrote: 'This unfortunate result stems not from this court's interpretation of Florida's probate law, but from the fact that Ms. Aldrich wrote her will using a commercially available form — an easy legal form — which did not adequately address her specific needs, apparently without obtaining any legal assistance.'
cautionary1:51It appears that Ms. Aldrich may have finally realized she needed legal assistance, but unfortunately that realization came too late.
reflective3:13
Principles
The court invoked the old adage 'pennywise and pound foolish' — the cost of drafting a will through a pre-printed form is likely substantially lower than hiring a knowledgeable lawyer, but the ultimate cost has the potential to far surpass the cost of hiring a lawyer at the outset.
cautionary2:18Because she didn't fill out the form correctly and didn't ask anyone to advise her, the court was unable to honor her wishes and her money went to people she did not intend to inherit her estate.
cautionary3:26You've worked your entire career to support yourself and the people you care most about — why risk it all with a do-it-yourself will?
motivational3:40
Strategy
The best defense is to get educated about how to avoid the mess that poor Anne left behind.
practical3:45
What you'll learn2
Clips from this episode11
Ann Aldrich of Keystone Heights, Florida used a standard will form in 2014 and left her property to her sister Mary, with everything going to her brother James if Mary died first — but the court ultimately ruled her nieces inherited Mary's assets, likely not what Anne wanted.
The court wrote that the 'unfortunate result stems not from this Court's interpretation of Florida's probate law but from the fact that M. Aldrich wrote her will using a commercially available form which did not adequately address her specific needs.'
The court invoked the adage 'pennywise and pound foolish' — the cost of drafting a will with a pre-printed form is lower upfront, but the ultimate cost of litigation can far surpass the cost of hiring a lawyer at the outset.
The time, effort, and expense of extensive litigation to prove a testator's true intent after death can necessitate expenditure of much more substantial amounts in attorney's fees than was avoided by using a pre-printed form.
Ann Aldrich had reportedly consulted an attorney shortly before her death who was drafting a new will, but she died just days before she could review it — and that testimony was declared inadmissible hearsay.
If your will is not drafted properly, your assets could pass on to somebody not even named in the document.
Ann was presumably trying to save money by using a standard form, but because she didn't fill it out correctly and didn't ask anyone to advise her, the court was unable to honor her wishes.
You've worked your entire career to support yourself and the people you care most about — why risk it all with a do-it-yourself will?
Using a commercially available, pre-printed will form without legal assistance can result in your assets passing to someone not even named in the document.
People think A simple estate means a simple will form will work fine without legal help.. Actually, Even seemingly simple estates can have unforeseen complications (e.g., a beneficiary dying first), and without proper legal drafting, the court may distribute your assets in ways you never intended.
People think Using a pre-printed or online will form is a safe and sufficient way to save money on estate planning.. Actually, A commercially available form may not adequately address your specific needs, and the resulting litigation costs can far exceed what you saved by not hiring a lawyer — as illustrated by the Ann Aldrich case.
