Source · Video
Ep. 5 - How Jim Built His Book of Business Inside a Big Law Firm
Jim Carlisle, a 30-year veteran at Dinsmore law firm, shares how he built a book of business inside a big law firm by adopting an entrepreneurial mindset, focusing on growth and exit planning for business owners, and consistently networking in his community. The episode emphasizes the importance of choosing a niche, maintaining a beginner's mentality, staying perpetually educated, and treating networking events as work by asking questions, gathering contact info, and following up. Host Ali Katz reinforces these strategies with her own parallel experience building a solo estate planning practice focused on families with young children.
Key moments6
- 0:03Introduction & Jim's Practice TodayAli introduces Jim Carlisle and the episode's theme of being the smartest and most approachable lawyer in the room. Jim describes his current focus on growth and exit planning with business owners.
- 2:24Building a Small Practice Inside Big LawJim explains how he started developing his own small clients from day one at a big law firm despite partner resistance, working long hours on both firm work and his own client development. Ali shares her parallel experience at Munger Tolles.
- 12:09Networking Strategy: Working the RoomJim details his disciplined approach to networking events — going where clients are, meeting new people, focusing conversations on the prospect, collecting contact info, and always following up.
- 16:00Niche Focus and the Power of SpecificityAli breaks down Jim's strategy and emphasizes the importance of knowing exactly who your clients are. She shares her own experience focusing on families with young children and how niching attracted a broader client base.
- 18:06Becoming a Trusted Advisor Through Deep QuestionsJim explains how asking business owners about growth, exit, net worth, and family goals earns trusted-advisor status and naturally generates all other legal work without having to pitch specific services.
- 24:54Staying Smart: Continuous Learning as a Competitive EdgeAli and Jim discuss the importance of reading what your clients read, staying current on industry news, and maintaining a beginner's mentality so you always have something relevant to say in any conversation.
The story
Before
Jim started at a big law firm where partners discouraged him from developing his own clients, and Ali felt miserable at Munger Tolles — making good money but feeling financially trapped, angry, and disconnected from meaningful work.
The turning point
Both independently decided to build their own small client practices within their big law firm environments, pitching partners case-by-case and carving out space to serve their own clients.
After
Jim built a mature, trusted-advisor practice over 30 years with long-term business owner clients; Ali eventually built the New Law Business Model to help other lawyers do the same.
Questions this episode answers1
How can a lawyer build a fulfilling practice outside of Big Law?
Lawyers who find corporate work unfulfilling can pivot to a client-centered model that offers time freedom, location independence, and meaningful impact — for example, through programs like New Law Business Model that help build a practice aligned with personal and financial goals.
Teachings11
Principles
You always have to invest in learning. You've got to keep pushing to learn every day — new things, new subject areas — and to stay current on your areas.
motivational8:24If you're not growing, you're shrinking. And the minute that you stop your mind from growing with new subjects and advancing your learning, your mind starts to shrink.
cautionary15:12When you choose a niche, everybody else comes to you. Once I started focusing on families with young children, the business owners, senior parents, high net worth families — everybody showed up.
motivational18:45I wasn't an order taker. They would say, 'Here's what I'm thinking — what do you think?' And I would have earned my right to have an opinion because I already knew what they were trying to achieve.
reflective20:24
Strategys
I would treat networking events like a work event. I forced myself to get around the room and meet new people and develop new relationships — not just find the group I already knew.
practical12:36Most of the time I spent talking with people, I would be talking about them — because they didn't care to hear about my law firm. They care about themselves and how I can help them.
practical14:00I talked about the most important need they have, and then by the way, if they didn't have a shareholder agreement problem, of course they were going to call me — because they trusted me with everything.
reflective19:58Read what your prospective clients are reading. If your clients are moms, read the parenting books. If they're sports agents, read what sports agents read. For Jim, it was the Wall Street Journal.
practical25:12
Tip
Don't spend too much time with one person at a networking event. Spend enough time to build a core relationship, get contact information, and then follow up after the event.
practical13:30
Warning
You are not going to build a business sitting behind your computer. Getting out there can be scary, uncomfortable, a pain — but it's the best way to do it.
cautionary23:03
Story
I built a small practice within a law firm at the origination of my practice — and over time, my small clients got bigger, my referral sources got promoted, and I found myself with a mature practice.
reflective4:48
What you'll learn3
Clips from this episode12
Jim built a small practice within a big law firm from the very start, focusing on business development and doing work for small clients right out of the gate — even when the firm discouraged it.
Big law was like drinking from a fire hose to start because you got a lot of training and expertise fast. You always have to invest in learning — pushing to learn new things and staying current every day.
Maintaining a beginner's mentality keeps your mind flexible, your neurons active, and actually keeps you living longer and feeling healthier. Learning never stops and can be genuinely exciting.
At networking events, treat them like a work event. Force yourself to get around the room and meet new people rather than gravitating to people you already know.
Don't spend too much time with any one person at a networking event. Spend enough time to build a core relationship, get contact information, and then follow up after the event.
Most of the time spent talking with prospects should be about them — find out enough about them so you can then talk about what you do that actually relates to them.
If you're not growing, you're shrinking. The minute you stop your pipeline, things go sideways. Keep your foot on the gas with both networking and continuous learning.
Read what your prospective clients are reading. For business owner clients, that was the Wall Street Journal every day — so that when a relevant subject comes up, you have something to say about it.
When you choose a niche, everybody else comes to you. Focusing marketing on one group doesn't rule out others — it actually attracts a broader range of clients.
Talking about growth and exit planning leads to the deepest client conversations — what's your business worth, what's your net worth, what do you want to leave your family. When clients trust you with that, they trust you with everything.
Being a trusted advisor — not an order taker — is the best position to be in. When you already know a client's full story and goals, they ask your opinion rather than just placing orders.
You are not going to build a business sitting behind your computer. Getting out there can be scary and uncomfortable, but it's the best way to build a practice — even once paid ads are working, networking should always be part of the mix.
